Come As You Are Inn LLC

Are you a New Yorker seeking a refreshing escape from the city's ceaseless energy, a place where genuine warmth and personalized care are at the forefront of your stay? Look no further than the enchanting Come As You Are Inn, nestled in the charming village of Sayville on Long Island. This isn't just another place to lay your head; it's a meticulously crafted experience, designed to make you feel like a cherished guest in a beloved home. In a world increasingly dominated by impersonal chain hotels, Come As You Are Inn stands out as a beacon of bespoke hospitality, offering a unique blend of comfort, character, and genuine human connection that is rare to find. For locals across the New York region, whether you're planning a weekend getaway, visiting family on Long Island, or simply craving a change of scenery, this inn promises a stay that is both memorable and deeply satisfying.

The philosophy behind Come As You Are Inn, as its name wonderfully suggests, is one of unpretentious welcome and authentic care. Innkeepers Mark and Ari have cultivated an environment where every guest feels seen, valued, and completely at ease. This dedication to guest experience is evident in every detail, from the moment you consider booking to the fond farewells. They understand that travel, even short-distance travel, should be a source of relaxation and enjoyment, not stress. Their approach transforms a simple overnight stay into a genuine hospitality encounter, ensuring that you depart feeling refreshed and revitalized. It’s this deep commitment to guest satisfaction that truly sets Come As You Are Inn apart from the myriad of lodging options available on Long Island.

Choosing a local, independent establishment like Come As You Are Inn also means investing in the vibrant community of Sayville. This inn contributes to the unique character of the village, offering an authentic alternative to more generic accommodations. It’s a place where you can experience the charm of Long Island firsthand, supported by individuals who are deeply rooted in and passionate about their local area. For New Yorkers looking to explore the hidden gems of their own state, supporting businesses like Come As You Are Inn not only enhances their travel experience but also strengthens the fabric of Long Island's diverse and welcoming communities.

The Come As You Are Inn is ideally situated at 59 Greene Ave, Sayville, NY 11782, USA. This charming location places it right in the heart of Sayville, a picturesque village on the south shore of Long Island, New York. Sayville itself is renowned for its quaint downtown, beautiful waterfront, and easy access to the Great South Bay and Fire Island. For New Yorkers, this makes the inn an incredibly accessible destination for a weekend escape or a longer retreat, offering a seamless transition from urban bustle to serene coastal charm.

For those traveling by car from New York City, Sayville is typically an approximately 1.5 to 2-hour drive, depending on traffic. The most common route involves taking the Long Island Expressway (I-495) eastbound to exit 60, then heading south on Ronkonkoma Avenue, which eventually leads into Sayville. Alternatively, you can take Sunrise Highway (Route 27) eastbound directly into Sayville. The inn's central location on Greene Avenue means it is easily navigable once you arrive in the village, often just a short distance from the main shopping and dining areas. Parking is typically available on-site or nearby, providing convenience for guests arriving by vehicle.

Public transportation is also a very viable and popular option for reaching Sayville from New York City. The Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) offers direct service from Penn Station in Manhattan to the Sayville station on the Montauk Branch. The train journey is scenic and comfortable, typically taking around 1 hour and 45 minutes to 2 hours. Once you arrive at the Sayville LIRR station, the Come As You Are Inn is often just a short taxi ride or a pleasant walk away, allowing guests to explore the village without the need for a car. This excellent connectivity makes the inn an appealing choice for those who prefer not to drive or are looking for an eco-friendlier travel option.

The inn’s location also provides convenient access to local attractions. Sayville Ferry Service, which provides passenger ferries to Fire Island destinations like Sailors Haven and Cherry Grove, is just a short drive or walk away. This makes Come As You Are Inn an ideal base for exploring the stunning beaches and vibrant communities of Fire Island. The close proximity to local restaurants, boutique shops, and historical sites in Sayville further enhances its appeal, allowing guests to fully immerse themselves in the local culture and offerings. The ease of access from the greater New York metropolitan area, combined with its charming village setting, makes Come As You Are Inn a truly convenient and desirable retreat.

• Personalized Welcome and Check-in: Innkeepers Mark and Ari prioritize greeting guests in person upon arrival, offering a warm welcome and a personal tour of common areas and room amenities.
• Delicious, Tailored Breakfast: A delicious breakfast is served every morning, with the innkeepers happy to accommodate various dietary needs and preferences, ensuring a delightful start to your day.
• Live Entertainment: Guests can enjoy live entertainment in the evening, with Mark, an accomplished pianist and church organist, often providing ambient music and piano playing.
• Comfortable and Well-Appointed Rooms: Rooms, such as the Mae West Room, are designed for comfort, featuring amenities like fireplaces and ample natural light.
• Engaging Conversation: Innkeepers Mark and Ari are noted for their engaging conversations, making guests feel like friends rather than just patrons.
• Freshly Baked Treats: Guests frequently enjoy freshly baked goodies provided daily, adding a delightful touch to their stay.
• Thoughtful Extras: The innkeepers extend their hospitality with thoughtful gestures, such as providing baked goodies for guests to take on their journey home.
• Dietary Accommodations: The inn is proactive in accommodating various dietary needs for breakfast, ensuring all guests can enjoy their meals without concern.
• Assistance with Local Information: Mark and Ari are a valuable resource for local insights, offering recommendations for dining, activities, and exploring Sayville and the surrounding Long Island area.

• Exceptional Personalized Service: The standout feature is the truly exceptional and personalized service provided by Innkeepers Mark and Ari. They are highly communicative, attentive to detail, and genuinely care about their guests' experience, often described as making guests feel like friends.
• Charming and Comfortable Accommodations: The inn offers very comfortable rooms, such as the Mae West Room, which are well-appointed with features like fireplaces and abundant natural light, contributing to a cozy and inviting atmosphere.
• Gourmet Breakfast Experience: Guests consistently rave about the delicious breakfast served daily, which is not only fresh but also thoughtfully prepared to accommodate various dietary needs. This personalized culinary experience is a significant highlight.
• Unique Live Musical Ambiance: Mark's talent as an accomplished pianist and church organist provides a unique and delightful ambient music experience in the evenings, adding a sophisticated and relaxing touch to the inn's atmosphere.
• Warm and Engaging Atmosphere: The inn fosters a warm, friendly, and engaging atmosphere, making it a stark contrast to impersonal chain hotels. This inviting environment encourages interaction and relaxation.
• Freshly Baked Delights: The daily provision of freshly baked treats is a consistent point of praise, adding a special, homely touch that enhances the overall guest experience.
• Attention to Detail: Mark and Ari's meticulous attention to every detail, from pre-arrival communication to providing take-away goodies, ensures a seamless and incredibly pleasant stay.
• High Customer Satisfaction and Recommendation: The inn consistently receives highly positive reviews and strong recommendations from guests who appreciate the superior level of service and comfort compared to other lodging options.

As a boutique inn focused on personalized service rather than volume, Come As You Are Inn may not frequently advertise broad, public promotions in the same way larger hotel chains do. However, their commitment to guest satisfaction often translates into unique forms of value and potential special arrangements. It is always recommended to contact Innkeepers Mark and Ari directly to inquire about any current or upcoming special offers, packages, or seasonal rates. They might offer discounts for extended stays, repeat guests, or special occasion packages (e.g., romantic getaways, anniversary celebrations) that include specific amenities or local experiences. Given their personalized approach, they are often open to discussing individual needs and may be able to tailor a package to your specific requirements. For instance, if you are planning a visit during an off-peak season, or for a longer duration, reaching out directly could potentially unlock a more favorable rate or an added amenity. Keep an eye on their official website or social media channels (if available) for any announcements, or simply give them a call – their friendly and communicative nature suggests they would be happy to discuss how they can make your stay even more special.

Address: 59 Greene Ave, Sayville, NY 11782, USA

Phone: (917) 288-1272

Mobile Phone: +1 917-288-1272

Given the intimate and personalized nature of Come As You Are Inn, direct communication is highly encouraged for bookings, inquiries, or any special requests. The innkeepers, Mark and Ari, are known for their responsiveness and personal touch, making a direct call the best way to get the most accurate and up-to-date information regarding availability, room details, dietary accommodations, and any specific needs you may have for your stay. You can reach them at the provided phone numbers to discuss your visit and experience their highly praised communicative approach firsthand.

For New Yorkers, whether residing in the bustling city or elsewhere on Long Island, Come As You Are Inn presents an exceptionally suitable and appealing lodging option. Its primary suitability stems from its distinctive offering of personalized, heartfelt hospitality that stands in stark contrast to the often-impersonal experience of larger hotel chains. For locals seeking a genuine escape and a true sense of being cared for, this inn delivers an experience that feels less like a transaction and more like a visit with dear friends.

The convenient location in Sayville, a charming and easily accessible village on Long Island, makes it an ideal spot for a quick weekend getaway without the hassle of extensive travel. New Yorkers can easily reach the inn by car or, even more conveniently, by the Long Island Rail Road, allowing for a stress-free journey to a serene environment. This accessibility means that a refreshing break is always within reach, offering a vital respite from the demands of urban living.

Beyond its location, the core strengths of Come As You Are Inn — the delicious, tailored breakfasts, the unique live piano entertainment, and the consistent attention to detail from Mark and Ari — create an atmosphere of warmth and comfort that is truly unparalleled. For locals, this means not just a place to sleep, but a destination in itself, where every morning begins with a delightful meal and evenings can be spent enjoying refined ambient music. This level of personalized care and the welcoming ambiance foster a sense of relaxation and rejuvenation that is often elusive in everyday life.

Furthermore, choosing Come As You Are Inn allows New Yorkers to support a local small business that genuinely cares about its guests and contributes to the unique character of Sayville. This aligns perfectly with a growing desire among locals to experience authentic, community-driven services and destinations. The inn offers an opportunity to explore a charming Long Island village, visit Fire Island, and enjoy local attractions, all while returning to a comfortable and hospitable "home away from home" at the end of the day.

In conclusion, Come As You Are Inn is not just a place to stay; it's an experience designed for New Yorkers who value genuine hospitality, comfort, and a touch of unique charm. Its accessibility, personalized service, and commitment to guest satisfaction make it an ideal choice for anyone looking for a memorable and truly refreshing escape on Long Island.

Come As You Are Inn LLC

59 Greene Ave, Sayville, NY 11782, USA