Lenhart's Cottages Introduce
Are you a New Yorker dreaming of a quintessential Montauk escape, where the salty air and the sound of crashing waves replace city sirens? Look no further than Lenhart's Cottages, a beloved retreat nestled along the scenic Old Montauk Highway. More than just a place to stay, Lenhart's offers a unique Montauk experience, combining rustic charm with breathtaking ocean views and direct access to the beautiful beaches that make this part of Long Island so iconic. For those seeking a serene getaway that feels like a true home away from home, rather than a bustling hotel, these cottages provide the perfect blend of privacy and convenience.
Lenhart's Cottages has long been a favored destination for New Yorkers looking to unwind and reconnect with nature. Its appeal lies in its tranquil atmosphere and the sense of spaciousness it offers, a welcome contrast to the often-cramped city living. As one satisfied guest enthusiastically shared, "Stayed here in February. Beautiful view of the ocean from the living room and the front bedroom. Large kitchen with outdoor grill. Have rented here many times and will continue coming back!" This highlights the enduring loyalty that Lenhart's inspires, a testament to its comfortable accommodations and stunning natural surroundings. Another visitor, reflecting on a recent stay, praised its location and amenities, noting, "Great Location, Dogs are welcome. Was assigned Unit 7A - Large unit with 4BR, 2Baths... Huge Kitchen well equipped / LR Open area - 1 TV in unit in Living Room... Uphill trek from parking area but worth it for the view! Quick and easy access to the beach. Very relaxing weekend - Management was very nice and great communication via text. Grounds were well maintained and very clean!" The opportunity to bring along furry family members, combined with spacious units and easy beach access, truly sets Lenhart's apart as an ideal Montauk retreat.
Lenhart's Cottages is conveniently located at 421 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA. This prime address places it directly across from the stunning beaches of Montauk, offering unparalleled ocean views and immediate access to the sand and surf. While Montauk is a beloved destination for its natural beauty and serene atmosphere, it's easily accessible from various parts of New York. For those driving from New York City, the journey typically takes a few hours, leading you directly along the scenic Long Island Expressway (I-495) to Montauk Highway (Route 27). Public transportation options also exist for reaching Montauk, including the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) to the Montauk station, from which a short taxi or rideshare can take you to the cottages. Please note that while the location offers excellent views, some cottages may require an uphill walk from the parking area, as mentioned in customer reviews, which contributes to the elevated views. Guests with mobility concerns are encouraged to inquire about specific unit locations when booking. The proximity to various local attractions, while maintaining a peaceful ambiance, makes Lenhart's an ideal base for exploring everything Montauk has to offer.
Services Offered:
- Furnished Cottages: Providing comfortable, fully furnished cottage units, often including multiple bedrooms, bathrooms, and living areas for a homely stay.
- Fully Equipped Kitchens: Each cottage typically features a spacious and well-equipped kitchen, complete with appliances and cookware, allowing guests to prepare their own meals and enjoy the convenience of a home-cooked vacation.
- Outdoor Grilling Facilities: Access to outdoor grills and picnic areas, perfect for enjoying al fresco dining amidst the beautiful Montauk scenery.
- Complimentary Wi-Fi: Ensuring guests remain connected with complimentary wireless internet access throughout their stay.
- Pet-Friendly Accommodation: Welcoming furry family members with specific policies and fees, making it an ideal choice for pet owners who want to bring their dogs along on their vacation.
- Limited Front Desk Hours: While offering privacy, management is available during limited hours and provides excellent communication via text for any guest needs or inquiries.
- Daily Housekeeping (may vary by booking platform/season): Some listings indicate daily housekeeping, providing a hotel-like convenience within a cottage setting.
Features / Highlights:
- Stunning Ocean Views: A primary highlight, many cottages offer direct and expansive views of the Atlantic Ocean from living rooms and bedrooms, providing a picturesque backdrop for your Montauk getaway.
- Direct Beach Access: Enjoy quick and easy access to the beautiful Montauk beaches, allowing guests to walk directly to the sand for swimming, sunbathing, or leisurely strolls along the shoreline.
- Spacious Multi-Bedroom Units: Ideal for families or groups, many cottages feature multiple bedrooms and bathrooms (e.g., 4BR, 2Baths), providing ample space and comfort for everyone.
- Cozy Fireplaces: Select cottages boast log-burning fireplaces, adding a charming and warm ambiance, particularly appealing during cooler seasons.
- Outdoor Seasonal Pool: Guests can enjoy a refreshing dip in the outdoor seasonal pool, offering another option for relaxation and fun, especially during warmer months.
- Well-Maintained Grounds: The property boasts well-maintained and clean grounds, contributing to a pleasant and inviting atmosphere for all guests.
- Proximity to Attractions: Lenhart's Cottages is conveniently located near Montauk's top attractions, including the Montauk Lighthouse, Gurney's Spa, Hither Hills State Park (great for hiking), and numerous fabulous restaurants, allowing for easy exploration of the area.
- Privacy and Relaxation: The cottage-style accommodation offers a greater sense of privacy and a more relaxed atmosphere compared to traditional hotels, making it perfect for a tranquil retreat.
- Air Conditioning: Cottages are equipped with air conditioning, ensuring comfort during the warmer Montauk summer days.
Promotions or Special Offers:
While specific promotions can vary based on seasonality and booking platforms, Lenhart's Cottages often provides opportunities for value and enhanced experiences. Guests should always check their preferred booking site or contact the cottages directly for the most current offers. Common considerations include:
- Off-Season Rates: Montauk, while beautiful year-round, is busiest in summer. Significant savings can often be found by booking stays during the shoulder seasons (spring and fall) or winter, when the atmosphere is quieter and rates are typically lower.
- Extended Stay Discounts: For those planning a longer vacation, inquire about potential weekly or multi-night discounts, which are common for cottage rentals.
- Direct Booking Benefits: Sometimes, booking directly through Lenhart's Cottages can offer exclusive rates or added perks not available on third-party sites.
- Seasonal Packages: Keep an eye out for special packages around holidays or local Montauk events, which might include bundled activities or dining credits.
Contact Information:
For reservations, inquiries about cottage availability, pet policies, or any other questions, please contact Lenhart's Cottages directly:
- Address: 421 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
- Phone: (631) 668-2356
Conclusion: Why Lenhart's Cottages is Suitable for Locals
For New Yorkers, Lenhart's Cottages represents the ideal Montauk escape, perfectly tailored for those seeking a tranquil yet engaging retreat from city life. Its suitability for locals is evident in several key aspects. Firstly, the cottage format offers a sense of privacy and spaciousness that is often a luxury in urban living, allowing families and groups to truly spread out and relax. The inclusion of fully equipped kitchens with outdoor grills means you can enjoy the flexibility of preparing your own meals, fostering a more relaxed and budget-friendly vacation, a welcome change from constant dining out.
The direct beach access is an unparalleled advantage, allowing spontaneous dips in the ocean or serene morning walks without the hassle of driving or parking. Furthermore, the pet-friendly policy is a huge draw for dog owners in New York, who often struggle to find quality accommodations that welcome their furry companions. This means no more leaving your beloved pet behind, making family vacations truly complete. The proximity to Montauk’s myriad attractions, from the historic lighthouse to renowned spas and hiking trails, ensures there’s always something to do, yet the cottages themselves offer a peaceful haven when you desire to unwind. Lenhart's Cottages provides the perfect blend of Montauk's rustic charm, essential amenities, and a welcoming atmosphere, making it an ideal, recurring destination for New Yorkers craving a genuine Long Island getaway. It’s a place where you can create lasting memories, year after year, just a short drive from the city.
Lenhart's Cottages Photos










Lenhart's Cottages Location
Lenhart's Cottages
421 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
Lenhart's Cottages
421 Old Montauk Hwy
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
290 Old Montauk Hwy
Panoramic View Resort & Residences
272 Old Montauk Hwy
Hither Woods Preserve
Montauk Point State Pkwy
Sunrise Guest House
681 Old Montauk Hwy
Surfside Inn
685 Old Montauk Hwy
Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort
693 Old Montauk Hwy Suite 5020
Hopping Frog Pond
Fairview Rd
Atlantic Bluffs Club Ltd
707 Old Montauk Hwy
Beachcomber Resort
727 Old Montauk Hwy
Breakers Montauk
769 Old Montauk Hwy
Beach Plum Resort
779 Old Montauk Hwy
Wavecrest Resort
170 Old Montauk Hwy
Lenhart's Cottages Reviews
Stayed here in February. Beautiful view of the ocean from the living room and the front bedroom. Large kitchen with outdoor grill. Have rented here many times and will continue coming back!
Feb 23, 2025 · Hope DorseyStayed 2 nights in April 2024 - Great Location, Dogs are welcome. Was assigned Unit 7A - Large unit with 4BR, 2Baths (1 king, 2 Queen/full, 2 twin beds) has 2 BR 1 Bath upstairs and 3 beds 1Bath downstairs. Huge Kitchen well equipped / LR Open area - 1 TV in unit in Living Room. Couches do not pull out. Extra pillows and bedding found in closets. Had a picnic table in front, small patio out back (no chairs out back). Uphill trek from parking area but worth it for the view! Quick and easy access to the beach. Very relaxing weekend - Management was very nice and great communication via text. Grounds were well maintained and very clean!Nearby activities: Great spots for Hiking - Montauk Lighthouse - Gurneys Spa - Fabulous Restaurants.Safety: Felt very safe on the grounds. Very well lit at night. Walk to the beach after sunset will need a lantern or flashlight.Walkability: All Up Hill! If you are handicapped or cannot walk up/down hills to your room, ask when making reservation. There were a few cottages down by the road, but I'm sure you will hear road noise at night.
Apr 29, 2024 · Karen Libby☀️Lenhart’s cottages were the perfect blend of cozy and quaint with touches of beach vibes that suited all of our families needs while we ventured Montauk. Located along the Old Montauk Highway these cottages are hidden along the quiet coastal road. Easy driving distance to “downtown” it was an amazing escape within the escape. Walking distance to a beach (decent amount of stairs) that was very quiet and felt private…we were lucky enough to see a whale venture its way along the coast🐳. Swimming pool available during the day as well which was never crowded. We will definitely be staying here again if available🤞🏼
Dec 27, 2023 · Jeffrey PammerOur cottage was the perfect blend of cozy and quaint with touches of beach vibes that suited all of our needs while we ventured Montauk. Located along the Old Montauk Highway these cottages are hidden along the quiet coastal road. Easy driving distance to “downtown” it was an amazing escape within the escape. Walking distance to a beach (decent amount of stairs.
Dec 30, 2023 · Michael NaussWe had such a great stay and would definitely come back! It’s directly across from the beach. You can hear the ocean from the cottages & depending on the cottage, you will have an ocean view. Short drive from shops & restaurants. The space was plenty for a couple + 2 small dogs.Huge unfenced yard behind the cottages. We had small ants consistently in the cottage and tried to keep food sealed up & as clean as possible - it was manageable.If you’re bringing dogs- the area is tick heavy (at least time of year we came). Our dog is on preventatives but after one walk to the beach (walking path has brush around it) we found 3-4 ticks crawling on her & around 10 overall on her.
Apr 29, 2022 · Jackie S
More Scenic Spot

290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

272 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

Montauk Point State Pkwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

681 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

685 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

693 Old Montauk Hwy Suite 5020, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

Fairview Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

707 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

727 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

769 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

779 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

170 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
Categories
Popular Camping Sites






Must-Read Camping Blog Posts
Most Searched Camping Sites
Trending Camping Blog Posts





