The Menhaden Introduce
For New Yorkers seeking a sophisticated and serene escape from the urban environment, the charming village of Greenport on Long Island's North Fork offers a truly delightful destination. Nestled within this historic maritime community, The Menhaden stands out as an "exceptional" boutique hotel that effortlessly blends "big city service" with the tranquil charm of a coastal retreat. It's more than just a place to stay; it's an experience designed to pamper and delight, making it an ideal choice for discerning travelers from the metropolitan area.
The Menhaden consistently receives rave reviews for its pristine condition, modern aesthetic, and an array of thoughtful touches that elevate the guest experience. From the "clean and modern" rooms and bathrooms that are in "pristine condition" to the complimentary "galley drinks and snacks" and "coffee service 24/7," every detail is meticulously curated. Guests are particularly enamored with the "beautiful rooftop with cozy seating and fire tables with bar service delivery," offering breathtaking "marina with beautiful sunsets or sunrises." This commitment to comfort, convenience, and unique amenities ensures that whether you "stay one night or a few, you won’t regret!" The Menhaden truly embodies a luxurious yet approachable Greenport experience, making it a highly recommended choice for any New Yorker looking to discover the North Fork's unique blend of elegance and laid-back charm.
The Menhaden boasts an unparalleled location at 207 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA. This prime address places it directly on the waterfront, offering picturesque views of the marina and providing immediate access to the vibrant heart of Greenport Village. For New Yorkers, reaching Greenport is a straightforward and enjoyable journey. You can drive east on the Long Island Expressway (I-495), which provides a scenic route through Long Island, or opt for the convenient Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) with direct train service to Greenport. The Hampton Jitney also offers comfortable bus service to the North Fork, with stops in Greenport.
Once you arrive at The Menhaden, its central location truly shines. It's described as being within "walking distance to numerous bars and restaurants," making it incredibly convenient for guests to explore Greenport's acclaimed culinary scene and lively nightlife without needing a car. The charming Main Street, with its unique boutiques, art galleries, and local shops, is just steps away. The iconic Greenport ferry, providing access to Shelter Island, is also within easy reach. Furthermore, being on Front Street, the hotel offers immediate proximity to the waterfront, allowing for leisurely strolls along the docks, enjoying the maritime atmosphere, or simply watching the boats. For New Yorkers looking to immerse themselves in the authentic Greenport experience, combining relaxation with easy access to all the village has to offer, The Menhaden's location is truly "perfect" and a significant highlight of any stay.
- Exceptional and Friendly Staff: Guests consistently praise the staff for being "very friendly and helpful," providing "great service all hours of the day/night," and readily assisting with anything needed via text or in person.
- 24/7 Coffee and Tea Service: Each floor is "supplied with excellent coffee/tea machine," ensuring fresh, complimentary hot beverages at any time.
- Complimentary Food Choices: Beyond coffee, guests enjoy "lots of free food choices," including "warmed up croissants" and other snacks available in the galley on each floor, a welcome alternative to a continental breakfast.
- Rooftop Bar Service Delivery: Enjoy "bar service delivery" to the beautiful rooftop, enhancing the relaxation experience by the fire pits.
- Concierge Services: Staff are readily available to offer recommendations and assistance, ensuring guests make the most of their Greenport visit.
- Daily Housekeeping: Rooms and the entire hotel are maintained in "pristine condition" and are "super clean."
- In-Room Glass Water Carafe: A thoughtful "little touch" that reduces waste and highlights an eco-conscious approach.
- Complimentary Galley Drinks and Snacks: Beyond breakfast items, guests have access to free drinks and snacks, adding significant value and convenience.
- Text-Based Service Requests: The ability to "just ask or text them" for anything needed streamlines guest requests and reflects modern, responsive service.
- Pet-Friendly Policy: While not explicitly mentioned in these reviews, many boutique hotels of this caliber offer pet-friendly options, best to confirm directly with the hotel.
- Pristine Modern Design: The hotel is characterized by its "clean and modern" aesthetic and "beautiful" decor, offering a sophisticated and inviting ambiance.
- Small Boutique Hotel with Big City Service: A key highlight is the blend of intimate boutique charm with the high standards and responsiveness of urban luxury hotels.
- Luxurious and Spacious Rooms: Rooms and bathrooms are described as being in "pristine condition" and offering ample space for comfort.
- Stunning Rooftop with Fire Pits: A major draw, featuring "cozy seating and fire tables," providing a spectacular setting to enjoy "beautiful sunsets or sunrises" over the marina.
- Complimentary Galley Offerings: The generous provision of 24/7 coffee/tea service and a wide array of free food choices (including warm croissants) on each floor is a unique and highly praised feature.
- Eco-Friendly Touches: The "in room glass water carafe to reduce waste" demonstrates a commitment to sustainability.
- Unbeatable Waterfront Location: Situated on Front Street, offering direct access to the marina and captivating views.
- Exceptional Walkability: Being "walking distance to numerous bars and restaurants" makes exploring Greenport effortless and enjoyable.
- Attentive and Responsive Staff: The ability to text staff for anything needed, combined with their friendly and helpful demeanor, ensures a seamless and comfortable stay.
- Overall High Satisfaction: Guests emphatically state, "Don’t hesitate to stay here because you won’t be disappointed. We will return for sure!!"
For New Yorkers planning a trip to Greenport, The Menhaden, as a high-end boutique hotel, often has various promotions and special packages to enhance your stay. While specific deals are best confirmed directly with the hotel, here are common types of offers you might find:
- Off-Season and Mid-Week Rates: Greenport is particularly popular in the summer. New Yorkers can often find more attractive pricing by visiting during the spring, fall, or winter, or by booking mid-week stays (Sunday through Thursday nights) when demand is lower. These periods offer a quieter, more intimate experience of the North Fork.
- Extended Stay Discounts: If you're planning a longer vacation, inquire about reduced rates for booking multiple nights or a week-long stay. This allows you to truly immerse yourself in the comfort and luxury of The Menhaden.
- Romantic Getaway Packages: Given its elegant ambiance and stunning rooftop views, the hotel might offer packages tailored for couples, possibly including sparkling wine, gourmet treats, or special dining experiences at local restaurants.
- Wine Country Experiences: As Greenport is in the heart of the North Fork Wine Country, the hotel might partner with local vineyards for exclusive tasting tours or transportation packages.
- Direct Booking Benefits: Sometimes, booking directly through the hotel's phone number or official website can unlock perks not available through third-party booking sites, such as a complimentary room upgrade (subject to availability) or a welcome amenity.
- Seasonal Specials: The hotel may introduce unique offers tied to local events, holidays, or seasonal themes, such as harvest season packages in the fall or cozy winter retreats.
To ensure you receive the best possible value and a personalized experience, New Yorkers are highly encouraged to call The Menhaden directly at the provided phone number. Their exceptional staff, known for their attentiveness and helpfulness, will be able to provide the most accurate and up-to-date information on current promotions and help tailor your booking to your specific needs.
To plan your exceptional stay at The Menhaden and experience the pinnacle of Greenport hospitality, please use the following contact details:
Address: 207 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA
Phone: (631) 333-2777
Mobile Phone: +1 631-333-2777
For New Yorkers, The Menhaden in Greenport is an absolutely ideal and highly suitable choice for a local getaway, perfectly blending sophisticated urban amenities with tranquil coastal charm. It stands out by offering "big city service" without the "big city" hassle, making it an accessible and luxurious escape from the demands of metropolitan life.
The hotel's pristine modern design and commitment to cleanliness resonate deeply with those accustomed to high standards. The "spacious" rooms and bathrooms in "pristine condition" ensure a truly comfortable and refreshing stay. What truly elevates The Menhaden for locals are the thoughtful, complimentary touches: the "galley drinks and snacks," the "coffee service 24/7," and the "warmed up croissants." These small luxuries add significant value and convenience, making you feel genuinely cared for from the moment you arrive.
Furthermore, the location on Front Street is simply "perfect." New Yorkers value walkability, and The Menhaden delivers, being "walking distance to numerous bars and restaurants," allowing for effortless exploration of Greenport's vibrant dining and entertainment scene. The stunning "beautiful rooftop with cozy seating and fire tables" offers a breathtaking setting for relaxation, providing an unparalleled vantage point for sunsets over the marina – a truly unique experience. The staff's exceptional friendliness and responsiveness, exemplified by their 24/7 service and willingness to assist via text, ensure a seamless and stress-free visit. Whether you're seeking a romantic retreat, a relaxing weekend with friends, or simply a luxurious change of scenery, The Menhaden promises an "exceptional" experience that will undoubtedly lead to repeat visits for discerning New Yorkers. It's a true gem that delivers on every promise.
The Menhaden Photos










The Menhaden Location
The Menhaden
207 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA
The Menhaden
207 Front St
The Harbor Front Inn
209 Front St
Greenporter Hotel
326 Front St
Tapestry House
503 Front St
The Inn At Harbor Knoll
424 4th St
American Beech Hotel
302 Main St
White Lions Inn Hotel
433 Main St
ZEY Hotel
437
The Gallery Hotel
441 Main St
Whaler's Guest House
151 Bay Ave
Wells House Bed & Breakfast
530 Main St
The Stirling House
104 Bay Ave
Sterling Harbor House B & B
125 Sterling St
The Menhaden Reviews
Exceptional! Small boutique hotel with big city service. Clean and modern. Absolutely love the little touches - galley drinks and snacks, coffee service 24/7, in room glass water carafe to reduce waste, beautiful rooftop with cozy seating and fire tables with bar service delivery, the list goes on and on. Great service all hours of the day/night - just ask or text them and they will do anything needed. Walking distance to numerous bars and restaurants makes this location perfect. Don’t hesitate to stay here because you won’t be disappointed. We will return for sure!!
May 18, 2025 · GWe got into this hotel by accident and were very pleasantly surprised.Here are the key points.1. The staff was very friendly and helpful2. The room, the bathroom were in pristine condition3. The hotel overall is super clean4. No continental breakfast - no problem because each floor is supplied with excellent coffee/tea machine with lots of free food choices (warmed up croissants were delicious)5. There is nicely furnished rooftop with the fire pits were you can see the marina with beautiful sunsets or sunrisesWhether you stay one night or a few, you won’t regret!
May 24, 2025 · Gene R.The room was a little small but otherwise this hotel is one the best places to stay in Greenport -if you want to stay in town. The service was spectacular and the rooms are very clean and designed well. They have these small kitchens for coffee, drinks, snacks on each floor. The roof top to hangout on is very cool with comfortable couches and gas fireplaces. I wish they had a restaurant. Other than that, it's a truly great experience and great place to stay.
May 23, 2025 · Gregg HMy experience at the Menhaden was idyllic and incomparable to any of the other hotels I’ve been in on the North Fork of Long Island, and the entire country for that matter. I was given a warm welcome by Mario, the gracious and accommodating manager/host of the hotel. He told me about the special features of the hotel, including its lovely gift shop and the free breakfast to be found in a breakfast room on each floor. I had arrived hungry at mid-afternoon, and was happy to find an array of healthy foods in the breakfast nook, like nuts, fruits, drinks, etc. Throughout the day and night the food choices varied and were refilled. There were crescents and jam nightly. My key opened the door to an immaculate and beautiful room. The room had a definite feel of Feng Shui, with it’s lack of unnecessary furniture, beautiful floor, chest of drawers, lighting, chair, lamp, and comfortable bed. I originally came to the hotel in order to be in the proximityof my friends, who live in Greenport, but the Menhaden was way more than just a place to crash for the night. I left feeling rejuvenated and relaxed, as if I had been on a true vacation.
Apr 03, 2025 · Nancy FelderWe stayed there for a quick weekend getaway and absolutely loved our experience. From check in with hot towels and warm welcome to chats with the staff over drinks and classic records. The hotel is chic, super clean and in a perfect location. The room was spacious and beautiful. The morning croissants and afternoon chocolate chip cookies were such a treat. We loved everything. Thank you.
Jan 09, 2025 · Hedieh Yazdanseta
More Scenic Spot

209 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

326 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

503 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

424 4th St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

302 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

433 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

437, 439 &, 441 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

441 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

151 Bay Ave, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

530 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

104 Bay Ave, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

125 Sterling St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA
Categories
Popular Camping Sites






Trending Camping Blog Posts





